‘Controversial’ study says meat and sugar equally bad

By Oscar Rousseau contact

- Last updated on GMT

Nearly 30% of Australians are classed as obese, according to the OECD
Nearly 30% of Australians are classed as obese, according to the OECD

Related tags: Meat, Meat consumption, Nutrition

Meat is just as bad as sugar when it comes to obesity causes and national dietary guidelines should recommend eating less meat, according to Australian researchers.

Meat consumption makes a “significant contribution​” to obesity, according to academics at the University of Adelaide, Australia, who have published a report examining the link between meat consumption and obesity in 170 countries.

The study looked at sugar and meat availability and found that the amount of both meat and sugar contributes 50% to the prevalence of global obesity.

Professor Maciej Henneberg, head of the Biological Anthropology and Comparative Anatomy Research Unit at the University of Adelaide, said the findings are “likely to be controversial​”. This is because researchers believe it “may make sense​” for official dietary guidelines to suggest reducing meat and sugar intake to stop people getting fatter.

‘Significant’ impact

While we believe it’s important that the public should be alert to the over-consumption of sugar and some fats in their diets, based on our findings we believe meat protein in the human diet is also making a significant contribution to obesity,​” said Henneberg.
The research, conducted by PhD student Wenpeng You, found that sugar and meat availability in a nation both explain 50% of obesity causes in society. After correcting differences for a nation’s GDP (gross domestic product), calorie consumption, levels of urbanisation and physical activity, the study found meat and sugar contributed another 13%.

You presented his research at the 18th International Conference on Nutrition and Food Sciences in Zurich, Switzerland.

Protein energy ‘surplus’

He said there is a “dogma​” in societies that fats and carbohydrates have a major effect on international obesity rates.

Weight is a big international problem as worldwide obesity has doubled since 1980, according to the European Association for the Study of Obesity.

Whether we like it or not, fats and carbohydrates in modern diets are supplying enough energy to meet our daily needs,​” said You. "Because meat protein is digested later ​[in the digestion process] than fats and carbohydrates, this makes the energy we receive from protein a surplus, which is then converted and stored as fat in the human body.​”

In the advanced word, Australia has one of the highest rates of obesity, behind the likes of the US, Mexico and New Zealand. Growing affluence, portion sizes and cheap, convenient food has led to 28.3% of Australian adults being classed as obese, according to an OECD study from 2011.

Related news

Show more

Related products

The unique natural anti-oxidant for meat applications

The unique natural anti-oxidant for meat applications

Kancor Ingredients Limited | 28-Feb-2019 | Technical / White Paper

Fresh meat is preferred in bright red colour but is highly prone to oxidation and is colour sensitive to extracts. Kancor’s OxiKan R, a highly refined...

Microbiological safety of raw-fermented sausages

Microbiological safety of raw-fermented sausages

Jungbunzlauer | 18-Feb-2019 | Technical / White Paper

Raw-fermented sausages are prone to the contamination with pathogens such as Salmonella and Listeria. Jungbunzlauer gives a new impetus to the exploration...

From trust grows success

From trust grows success

K+G Wetter | 09-Oct-2017 | Data Sheet

The award winning company Wünsch’s Fleischspezialitäten sets new quality standards for meat products – using machines made by K+G Wetter.

Related suppliers


More nuanced then that

Posted by sam,

The researchers aren't precisely saying that sugar and meat are nutritionally the same. They are just claiming that both can equally contribute to obesity, not an all together crazy thing to suggest.

the bit about protein digestion occurring later, thus making meat more likely to be handled as surplus energy, however, does seem a bit far fetched and contrived.

Report abuse

More Junk Science

Posted by Graybull,

So called "researcher's are becoming more political everyday in pushing their wacko agenda.

IF you believe that meat is on par with sugar.......nutritionally.......maybe I can sell you some nice ocean front property in Nebraska

Report abuse